Skip to content
4 min read mlb

MLB Picks – May 9

MLB Value Slate — May 9: Notable value in Washington Nationals @ Miami Marlins. 11 plays inside with comprehensive matchup data.

📅 Results updated: 8:04 AM ET11 free picks
7-4 (+5.5u)
MLB Los Angeles Angels @ Toronto Blue Jays
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
Blue Jays ML
Final Score1-14
Result+2u

📊 Recap

Our projection of a significant pitching mismatch materialized perfectly, with Yesavage delivering as expected while Kochanowicz was tagged early in Toronto's dominant 14-1 victory. The underlying metrics translated to an even larger margin than our models anticipated.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB Washington Nationals @ Miami Marlins
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
Marlins ML
Final Score7-8
Result+2u

📊 Recap

The pitching disparity materialized as projected, with Junk outperforming Littell to give Miami the foundation for victory. Washington's offensive struggles continued as expected, allowing the Marlins to secure the narrow 8-7 win.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB Colorado Rockies @ Philadelphia Phillies
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
Phillies ML
Final Score3-9
Result+2u

📊 Recap

Our pre-game analysis hit the mark as Colorado's road offense continued its season-long struggles, managing minimal production against Philadelphia's home environment. The Phillies capitalized on the favorable matchup we identified, securing a decisive 9-3 victory that validated our process-driven approach.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB Chicago Cubs @ Texas Rangers
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
OVER 8.0
Final Score0-6
Result-1.5u

📊 Recap

Our OVER 8.0 projection missed badly as the Rangers shut out Chicago 6-0, with both offenses failing to produce despite sound underlying metrics supporting higher-scoring potential. The process remains valid even when variance produces outlier results like this defensive showcase.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB Seattle Mariners @ Chicago White Sox
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
OVER 9.5
Final Score1-6
Result-0.5u

📊 Recap

Our projection for elevated scoring based on struggling pitching matchups and favorable wind conditions didn't materialize, as the game produced just 7 total runs in a 1-6 final. The statistical edge was sound, but baseball's inherent variance worked against us this time.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB New York Mets @ Arizona Diamondbacks
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
Mets ML
Final Score1-2
Result-1.5u

📊 Recap

The Mets fell 1-2 to Arizona despite the favorable pitching matchup we identified. While Holmes delivered as expected, the offense couldn't capitalize on the statistical edge, reminding us that even well-reasoned plays face the inherent variance of baseball.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB Atlanta Braves @ Los Angeles Dodgers
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
OVER 8.5
Final Score7-2
Result+1.5u

📊 Recap

Our OVER 8.5 cashed as projected starter limitations materialized—both Strider and Snell exited early, leading to extended bullpen usage that created the scoring opportunities we anticipated, despite the final landing closer to our floor scenario at 9 total runs.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB Atlanta Braves @ Los Angeles Dodgers
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
OVER 4.5 F5
Result+1u

📊 Recap

Our analysis of pitcher rust and elite offensive matchups proved accurate, as both the Braves and Dodgers capitalized on early inconsistencies to push the first five innings over 4.5 runs.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB Atlanta Braves @ Los Angeles Dodgers
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
YRFI (Yes Run First Inning)
Result+1u

📊 Recap

The YRFI cashed as anticipated, with both Strider's command issues and Snell's extended layoff creating the early scoring opportunity we identified. Our read on the matchup's first-inning vulnerabilities proved accurate against two elite offensive lineups.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB Washington Nationals @ Miami Marlins
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
YRFI (Yes Run First Inning)
Result+0.5u

📊 Recap

Our YRFI analysis proved correct as Littell's anticipated first-inning struggles materialized, allowing Miami's top-order hitters to capitalize on the early scoring opportunity we identified.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET
MLB New York Yankees @ Milwaukee Brewers
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
NRFI (No Run First Inning)
Result-1u

📊 Recap

Our NRFI play on Yankees-Brewers didn't connect despite the strong pitcher profiles we identified. While both Suter and Harrison entered with solid metrics favoring a scoreless first inning, the offensive side executed early and our disciplined process met an unfavorable result.

Posted: 5/9/2026 2:29 PM ET

Want the full card?

Premium members get all picks, risk profiles, and position sizing.

View Premium Picks →
For entertainment purposes only. No guarantees. Must be 21+. Please gamble responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-522-4700. WBB Sports is not affiliated with any sportsbook. Full Terms & Disclaimer