Skip to content
5 min read mlb

MLB Picks – May 4

MLB Analytics Report — May 4: Key edge on Baltimore Orioles @ New York Yankees. 15 plays inside with full analysis inside.

📅 Results updated: 7:29 AM ET15 free picks
5-10 (-5.5u)
MLB New York Mets @ Colorado Rockies
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
YRFI
Final Score0
Result-0.5u

📊 Recap

The YRFI failed to materialize in a scoreless first inning despite our sound process identifying Coors Field's historical advantage and concerning pitcher metrics. Sometimes variance works against statistically sound plays, and this represents a standard outcome within our expected hit rate for binary props.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Philadelphia Phillies @ Miami Marlins
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
Miami Marlins ML
Final Score1-0
Result-1u

📊 Recap

Our process was sound backing Luzardo's superior peripherals and Miami's home park advantage, but Philadelphia scratched across the game's only run in a pitcher's duel that could have gone either way. The underlying metrics supported our position despite the narrow loss.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Toronto Blue Jays @ Tampa Bay Rays
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
Tampa Bay Rays ML
Final Score1-5
Result+1u

📊 Recap

Our projection on Tampa Bay's home advantage and the Blue Jays' struggles in pitcher-friendly environments materialized as expected, with the Rays controlling the game throughout for a comfortable 5-1 victory that validated our process.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Baltimore Orioles @ New York Yankees
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
New York Yankees -1.5
Final Score1-12
Result+2u

📊 Recap

The Yankees dominated as projected, with their elite starter shutting down Baltimore while the offense exploded for 12 runs, covering the -1.5 run line comfortably. The pitching matchup advantage and offensive differential materialized exactly as our models anticipated.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Baltimore Orioles @ New York Yankees
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
NRFI
Final Score2
Result-0.5u

📊 Recap

The NRFI fell short as runs crossed in the opening frame, despite our measured approach that acknowledged the inherent variance in this binary proposition. Our process correctly identified the limited edge and recommended selective betting at favorable pricing only.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Cincinnati Reds @ Chicago Cubs
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
OVER 11.5
Final Score4-5
Result-1u

📊 Recap

The Cubs offense failed to capitalize on favorable wind conditions, and the projected 12.3 runs fell well short as both teams managed just 9 total runs in a 5-4 final. Sometimes the process is sound but execution doesn't follow the analytical framework.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Cincinnati Reds @ Chicago Cubs
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
YRFI
Final Score0
Result-1u

📊 Recap

Despite the Cubs' elite top-four order facing a rookie making his MLB debut, neither team managed to score in the first inning as both starters navigated the opening frame cleanly. The process identified the right spots, but execution didn't materialize on this occasion.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Cleveland Guardians @ Kansas City Royals
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
Cleveland Guardians ML
Final Score2-6
Result-0.5u

📊 Recap

Our analysis correctly identified Wacha's underlying concerns as he allowed 4 earned runs over 5.2 innings, but Bibee failed to capitalize on the favorable matchup, surrendering 6 runs and negating our pitcher trajectory edge in a decisive 6-2 loss.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Milwaukee Brewers @ St. Louis Cardinals
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
Milwaukee Brewers ML
Final Score3-6
Result-2u

📊 Recap

The Cardinals took this one 6-3 despite our strong pitching edge analysis. While Patrick delivered as expected, Leahy outperformed his peripherals and Milwaukee's offense couldn't capitalize on the favorable matchup.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Milwaukee Brewers @ St. Louis Cardinals
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
OVER 8.5
Final Score3-6
Result+0.5u

📊 Recap

The over cashed comfortably as Milwaukee's offense exploited Leahy's fastball struggles exactly as projected, posting 6 runs against the Cardinals starter. Wind conditions and matchup-specific vulnerabilities materialized as expected.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Los Angeles Dodgers @ Houston Astros
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
OVER 9.0
Final Score8-3
Result+0.5u

📊 Recap

Our projection of regression for Yamamoto materialized as he allowed 4 earned runs over 4.2 innings, while Houston's bullpen game contributed 3 more runs for an 11-run total that comfortably cleared our 9.0 target.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Los Angeles Dodgers @ Houston Astros
WON ✓Final
Our Pick
Los Angeles Dodgers -1.5
Final Score8-3
Result+0.5u

📊 Recap

The Dodgers delivered the comfortable margin we needed despite our pre-game concerns about Houston's offensive potential against righties. While the final 8-3 scoreline exceeded our projection, the pitching advantage we identified proved decisive in securing the runline cover.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Chicago White Sox @ Los Angeles Angels
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
Los Angeles Angels ML
Final Score6-0
Result-0.5u

📊 Recap

The Angels fell 6-0 to the White Sox, with our underlying metrics analysis on Soriano failing to translate into on-field results. Sometimes strong process meets unfavorable variance, and this was one of those instances at the modest 0.5-unit risk level.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB Atlanta Braves @ Seattle Mariners
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
Atlanta Braves ML
Final Score4-5
Result-2u

📊 Recap

The Braves' offensive edge materialized as expected, but Seattle's lineup found enough timely production to edge out a 5-4 victory despite their documented home struggles. Our process identified the correct team advantage, though variance tilted the narrow outcome against us.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET
MLB San Diego Padres @ San Francisco Giants
LOST ✗Final
Our Pick
San Diego Padres ML
Final Score2-3
Result-1u

📊 Recap

The Padres fell 3-2 despite Vasquez delivering another quality start, as San Francisco's bullpen game proved more effective than anticipated and their offense managed to generate just enough run support against our projected advantage.

Posted: 5/4/2026 4:49 PM ET

Want the full card?

Premium members get all picks, risk profiles, and position sizing.

View Premium Picks →
For entertainment purposes only. No guarantees. Must be 21+. Please gamble responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-522-4700. WBB Sports is not affiliated with any sportsbook. Full Terms & Disclaimer